A spokesman for the non-governmental organisation Global Witness says it holds serious concerns that corrupt Congolese officials could be benefiting from such deals.
Meanwhile, poverty in Congo continues to worsen, with 70 per cent of the population said to be mal-nourished and vast swathes of the country still without reliable electricity or running water.
Gertler, who spends most of his week in the Congo before flying back to his family in Israel to spend Sabbath with his wife and nine children, thinks he is doing nothing but good for the country's people.
He points to his philanthropy and, in an interview with Bloomberg Markets magazine , even declared: "I should get a Nobel Prize."
But officials at the International Monetary Fund seem to take a different view. Last week, the IMF stopped a US$500 million ($592 million) loan to the Congo because of its concerns over the way Kabila's Government had sold minerals to a company said to be controlled by Gertler. A few days later, his biggest partner in the Congo, London Stock Exchange-listed mining company Eurasian Natural Resources Corporation (ENRC), severed its relationship with him.
Increasingly, opposition politicians, NGOs and other critics are claiming Gertler's grip on the country's mineral wealth is starting to slip. "Western companies don't want to do business with him anymore. He's over," one opposition activist told the Independent.
But just how did this young businessman come to gain such a powerful hold over the president of one of the biggest and most troubled nations on the planet?
For the answer, we must return to the newly renamed Democratic Republic of Congo of 1997.
The US-backed dictator Mobutu Sese Seko has just been ousted from his three-decade reign.
Although he calls himself president, Mobutu's nemesis, Laurent Kabila, has still not grabbed full control of the country. He desperately needs funds to continue his push. Enter Dan Gertler.
At just 23, the diamond trader had a taste for adventure and an eye for a deal. Having learned the trade at the foot of his father and grandfather, he had been buying diamonds in war-torn Angola and Liberia, and flying them to the wealthy trading centres of the US, Israel and India. The new Congo must have seemed too good a chance to miss.
Shortly after he arrived in the city of Kinshasa, he secured an introduction to Laurent Kabila's son by the city's chief rabbi.
Also in his 20s, Joseph Kabila had recently been made the leader of his father's army. Gertler was taking an increasingly big role in the family diamond empire. The unlikely duo hit it off instantly.
Joseph Kabila soon introduced Gertler to his father, who recognised in the rich Israeli a quick way to fund his war. According to Gertler, Laurent Kabila made him an offer: get me $20 million in cash to fund my fight, and I give you a monopoly over Congo's diamond sales. Thanks to Gertler's wealthy connections and business clout, he raised the money within a few days, putting it into Congo's central bank account in Switzerland.
As his uncle Shmuel Schnitzer told Bloomberg Markets: "The guy has guts. This is the basic thing about him."
To say Gertler backed the right horse is an understatement. Although Laurent Kabila was assassinated by a bodyguard in 2001 and the diamond monopoly was later rescinded, Gertler's influence on Joseph Kabila also proved incredibly lucrative as he took over from his father.
Today, largely thanks to the exploitation of the Congo's huge mineral rights, Gertler is one of the richest men in the world, with a fortune of more than US$2 billion.
Global Witness has been dogged in its criticism of Gertler's business dealings, painstakingly assembling paperwork and following the money in his complex transactions. More often than not, the money trail ends in his offshore companies in the British Virgin Islands.
The IMF insists sales of the Congo people's assets should be done openly and transparently, rather than in backroom deals.
For his part, Gertler declares this sort of openness is up to the Government, not him: "We're a private company. Why should we announce?" he says.
"The lies are screaming to the heavens."
In the meantime, as millions of dollars of minerals are shipped out of Congo every day, the country remains one of the world's poorest.
- Independent