He said there have only been three times the central bank has moved rates by 75 points or more.
“During the Global Financial Crisis, when Lehman’s collapsed and banking balance sheets looked dreadful, we actually had a 100-basis-point cut and two 150-basis-point cuts in short shrift. But that was at a time when we were really worried that the entire banking sector would fall over,” Toplis said.
“Then we went into the global pandemic. It delivered a 75-basis-point cut there, and of course in the first days and weeks of that pandemic, we really felt really worried about what was going to happen. We had forecasts of unemployment rates rising to 20% and the world falling over.
“The last time they moved was actually 75 basis points upward when the CPI [Consumers Price Index] surprised them by a massive 0.8%. The recent CPI surprise was 0.1%, which really isn’t a surprise at all.”
Toplis said there isn’t anything disastrous happening to the economy to justify such a large cut and it could run the risk of pushing inflation back up again.
The economist said interest rates need to come down below 4% to stimulate the economy.
But he said they can’t drop too quickly because consumers have borrowed on short terms and will get the financial perks of lower rates much sooner.
“Most people are rolling over six months’ mortgage interest rates so they’re going to get their bang for their buck quite quickly. We all talked a lot about the tax cuts and what that was going to deliver, that was sort of $20 a week for the average punter.
“But these mortgage rate cuts for some people are delivering hundreds of dollars a week. Now, that will change [spending] behaviours, but we just need to be conscious that we don’t actually just flood the economy with money again and not see what impact it’s having.”
Toplis said there is no need to panic because it is clear the RBNZ wants to get interest rates down to get the economy going again.
