Logan Paul, a 27-year-old boxer and social-media influencer, became interested in crypto last year after business associates introduced him to the world of NFTs. Photo / Sinna Nasseri, New York Times
Logan Paul, Paul Pierce and other celebrities have promoted risky and obscure digital currencies, sometimes failing to mention their conflicts of interest.
Logan Paul had a message for his 6 million Twitter followers: He was "all in" on a new cryptocurrency called Dink Doink.
According to the project's creator, Dink Doink investors would receive shares of a cartoon character, entitling them to a portion of the proceeds if the googly-eyed figure ever appeared in a TV show or movie. Last June, Paul, a 27-year-old boxer and social-media influencer, praised Dink Doink on Twitter and in a public Telegram chat, before endorsing it again on his podcast, Impaulsive.
But by mid-July, the price of Dink Doink had plummeted to a fraction of a cent, and Paul was facing an online backlash. In his endorsements, he had failed to mention some relevant information: He and the project's creator were friends, and they had come up with the idea for the cryptocurrency together. He had also received a large allocation of Dink Doink coins when it launched.
"I don't know what went absurdly wrong," Paul said in an interview. "That's the project from hell, and I just wiped my hands of that."
The collapse in crypto prices this month has renewed scrutiny of the celebrity marketers who sell virtual currencies to the masses. Over the last year, actor Matt Damon and comedian Larry David have starred in high-profile TV commercials for crypto platforms, trumpeting digital assets as an unmissable moneymaking opportunity. Those ads drew criticism from crypto sceptics, but they were tied to mainstream companies with hundreds of millions of dollars in revenue.
A far seedier form of crypto promotion has flourished on social media, rife with undisclosed conflicts of interest and exaggerated claims about skyrocketing profits. Celebrity influencers like Kim Kardashian and Floyd Mayweather have made millions of dollars endorsing specific and often dubious crypto investments, urging fans to buy obscure coins that quickly crashed in value, or shilling little-known collections of nonfungible tokens, the unique digital files known as NFTs.
In some cases, promoters like Paul have admitted that they failed to disclose personal or financial ties to projects advertised on their feeds, a potential violation of federal marketing regulations. And even before the crypto market's recent downturn, a series of these influencer-backed ventures had crashed spectacularly, hurting amateur traders and prompting lawsuits that could force some celebrities to compensate investors for their losses.
"You have this shameless profiteering from celebrities and others, who aren't at all disinterested or impartial," said John Reed Stark, a former chief of the internet enforcement branch at the Securities and Exchange Commission. "There is a lot of potential for harm."
Crypto entrepreneurs hire influencers to push up the value of their digital currencies, hoping to ignite the sort of online hype that briefly turned Dogecoin, a joke currency based on a meme, into one of the most valuable crypto investments.
Some promoters are not well known outside crypto circles but have large followings on social media, where they broadcast market tips, interspersed with sponsored content. Others are major celebrities like Kardashian, who is facing a lawsuit from investors over her marketing of an obscure cryptocurrency called EthereumMax.
The amounts paid to crypto promoters can be astronomical. An NFT project called Hive Investments has been recruiting influencers, offering payments as large as US$400,000 ($612,000), according to a presentation reviewed by The New York Times.
Jordan Belfort, the former stockbroker whose memoir inspired the 2013 movie The Wolf of Wall Street, was once offered US$250,000 ($382,000) to change his Twitter profile picture to an NFT. Belfort, who recently rebranded himself as a crypto guru, turned down the offer.
"We don't want to be a part of things that basically exist purely to separate people from their money," said Matt Hirschberg, Belfort's business partner. "I've had people offer us guarantees of up to at least $10 million just to get involved."
Crypto promotion occupies a legal grey area. Under federal law, people marketing securities are required to publicly disclose payments for promotions. In 2018, Mayweather paid more than US$600,000 to settle SEC charges that he had failed to properly disclose his compensation for marketing initial coin offerings, the crypto equivalent of an initial public offering on Wall Street. But the rule he broke applies only to securities, like stock in a company, and it is unclear which crypto products meet that legal standard.
Crypto promoters could also run afoul of the Federal Trade Commission's rules, which require marketers of all kinds to disclose when they have a financial stake in the projects they endorse.
"Companies and the social media influencers of the world view this as the Wild West," said David Klein, a lawyer in New York who specialises in marketing rules. "The old-world laws still apply, and you have to follow the guidelines. Otherwise, the regulators will come calling."
Even celebrities who disclose crypto payments have found themselves in legal trouble. Last summer, Kardashian endorsed EthereumMax in an Instagram post with a brief disclaimer at the bottom: "#ad." Few crypto insiders had heard of EthereumMax, which is different from Ethereum, one of the most popular crypto platforms.
The promotion led to a surge of trading, but EthereumMax's price soon collapsed. This year, nine traders who had bought EthereumMax sued Kardashian, the project's founders and other promoters, including Mayweather and former basketball star Paul Pierce, accusing them of disguising their control over EthereumMax tokens and circulating "misleading" advertisements.
According to the lawsuit, Pierce received more than 15 trillion EthereumMax tokens in exchange for tweets endorsing the coin. None of the tweets excerpted in the lawsuit mentioned a business relationship with the token's creators. Shortly after promoting the project, the lawsuit claimed, Pierce sold his tokens — an apparent "pump and dump" operation in which he profited by encouraging fans to buy the tokens, before selling his own holdings at a higher price.
A lawyer for Kardashian said the suit's allegations "lack merit." Mayweather, Pierce and the project's founders did not respond to requests for comment.
As crypto prices have crashed, investors have also turned on lower-profile influencers who post sponsored content on social media. Ben Armstrong, a crypto influencer with almost 1 million Twitter followers, runs a YouTube channel where he discusses market trends and talks up his favourite projects. He used to charge startup founders US$40,000 for a YouTube interview, but discontinued the service this year after his price sheet was posted publicly by an influential crypto sleuth.
Some of the projects that Armstrong promoted were small-time, experimental crypto ventures that eventually encountered problems. In those cases, he said, he considered himself a victim, too.
"They're preying on the novice crypto influencer who just got popular and is trying to figure out what they should and shouldn't be doing," he said. "It's hard to go from 12,000 followers to a million in one year and make all the right decisions."
Paul rose to fame as a video blogger and an occasional actor; YouTube once reprimanded him for publishing footage of a dead body he found in a Japanese forest. Over the years, he has parlayed his internet fame into an eclectic array of entrepreneurial pursuits, including a line of energy drinks.
Paul became interested in crypto last year as the market for NFTs started booming. In a recent interview, he acknowledged that he was still learning how to navigate the crypto market, even as he tried to profit from the technology. "I'm an extreme ideas person, not much of an executor," he said.
Paul was involved in some of the initial brainstorming for the Dink Doink project. But the venture was ultimately spearheaded by one of his roommates, Jake Broido, who gave Paul 2.5 per cent of the tokens that were initially issued.
In a tweet last June, Paul called it one of the "dumbest, most ridiculous" cryptocurrencies he had encountered, and circulated a video of a cartoon character singing sexually explicit lyrics. "That's why I'm all in," he added. He also appeared in a shaky-cam video on Telegram in which he hailed Dink Doink as possibly his favourite crypto investment.
The campaign was a flop, and Paul was pilloried by YouTube critics. The price of Dink Doink hovered well below a cent, before falling even further in value over the summer. Paul said he had never sold his tokens or profited from the project. But he said he regretted promoting the coin without disclosing his financial stake. "I definitely didn't act as responsibly as I should have," he said.
Not long after Dink Doink's crash, Paul started an NFT collection called CryptoZoo, which was widely mocked for featuring stock images of animals. Paul blamed the staff who helped run the project for CryptoZoo's problems. Now, he's working with a new team on a crypto venture called Liquid Marketplace, which uses blockchain technology to let investors buy fractions of physical objects.
The recent crypto crash "will definitely weed out the weak," Paul said. But he added that it had also made him rethink some of his promotions, after he personally lost US$750,000.
"I don't want anyone to feel like they've been screwed because of any sort of move they've made because of me," he said.
Paul knows what it feels like to be on the receiving end of a deal gone sour. Last year, he fought Mayweather in a Las Vegas boxing exhibition that drew more than 1 million pay-per-view customers. Months later, Paul claimed that Mayweather still hadn't fully compensated him for the fight. (Mayweather responded: "Be happy with the biggest payday you ever got in your life.")
The event itself was a cryptocurrency promotion: Fans were encouraged to buy tickets using EthereumMax.
This article originally appeared in The New York Times.
Written by: David Yaffe-Bellany
Photographs by: Sinna Nasseri, Scott McIntyre and Hunter Abrams
© 2022 THE NEW YORK TIMES
A2 Milk shares surge to help lift local market higher.