House prices continued to drop in November, the largest year-on-year drop since the Global Financial Crisis (GFC).
Rising interest rates and falling prices and sales are making the housing market more uncertain, according to the Real Estate Institute (REINZ).
The institute’s House Price Index, which measures the changing value of residential property, fell 13.7 per cent in November on the year before, when the market was at its peak.
It said the median house price dropped $10,000 to $810,000 from October, with prices down 12.4 per cent on a year ago.
Meanwhile, Quotable Value’s house price index for November showed that the decreases in houses prices had slowed - falling 2.9 per cent nationally over the three months ending in November, in contrast with the 3.9 per cent quarterly reduction reported at the end of October.
Its index found the average house value to now be 10.2 per cent lower than at the start of 2022, coming in at $945,568 with a reduction in price of $107,747.
Which regions are taking the biggest tumble?
QV said house prices had fallen most significantly in New Zealand’s main urban centres in 2022.
It said the largest drops have been Wellington (-18.7 per cent), Palmerston North (-14.5 per cent), Hastings (-12.5 per cent), Auckland (-12.2 per cent), Napier (-12 per cent), Dunedin (-11.5 per cent), Hamilton (-11.3 per cent) and Tauranga (-9.3 per cent).
Wellington has ranked bottom of the index for 12 consecutive months, REINZ chief executive Jen Baird said.
But they were seeing positive indicators in the House Price Index (HPI) that the intensity of downward pressure on property value was easing in the region, with Wellington being the sixth best performer at 2.1 per cent, she said.
Auckland had the second greatest decrease in HPI movement, with an annual decrease on the index of 18.4 per cent.
Which regions are more resilient
The QV house price index showed Queenstown to be the only region showing a positive home value growth for the year (5.4 per cent).
Although still dropping, QV said Marlborough (-1.3 per cent), New Plymouth (-2.2 per cent) and Christchurch (-3.3 per cent) were the next most resilient regions.
While Trade Me property sales director Gavin Lloyd said not every region saw property prices tumble in November on their index either.
“Northland (+12 per cent), West Coast (11 per cent) and Taranaki (+10 per cent) bucked the trend with their average asking prices jumping by more than 10 per cent year-on-year last month.”
And REINZ found the West Coast achieved a record median price, up 20.0 per cent annually to $420,000, and Southland reached an equal high (last reached in February 2022) - up 10.5 per cent annually to $475,000.
Christchurch is one of the most resilient regions. according to Quotable Value’s house price index. Photo / Getty Images
Agents were reporting hesitancy among buyers, but there were signs sentiment was shifting.
“Agents around the country say sellers are realistic, they are meeting the market, they are entering negotiations.”
In November, REINZ recorded 5525 sales.
A ‘good time’ for buyers
“If you can make the finances work, this is a good time to be a buyer,” Baird said.
There was significantly more stock on the market and the market was less competitive, owner-occupiers remained a strong presence, and investors had largely stepped back - for now, she said.
For those sidelined by the frenzied 2021 market, with house prices down 12.4 per cent, now was a great time to take another look at what was out there, Baird said.
“It’s been a crazy couple of years in real estate with massive growth followed by a pretty significant correction,” QV chief operating officer David Nagel said.
The last time anything similar was seen was after the Global Financial Crisis in 2008, he said.
“But that was an entirely different kettle of fish to what we’re going through right now.
“The market was behaving in a generally orderly fashion until that point, with gradual, sustainable growth - whereas the growth we saw during the first two years of the Covid-19 pandemic was far from gradual and sustainable.
“Home values increased by nearly 30 per cent nationally in 2021. In 2022, they’ve fallen by less than half that much on average, so there’s clearly still some way to go until we’re back at pre-pandemic levels.
“Fortunately, our economy hasn’t taken a hit like it did in 2008, so unemployment remains very low - at least for now.”
How the OCR and interest rates are affecting house prices
“In late November, the Reserve Bank of New Zealand (RBNZ) raised the OCR by a record 75 basis points to 4.25 per cent. The central bank also forecasts a peak of 5.5 per cent next year and predicts a further rise in inflation,” Baird said.
The immediate effect on the real estate market was more hesitancy, she said.
“Buyers are again weighing up the likely impact on mortgage rates with current downward pressure on property prices. Those thinking of selling are again looking at the market and asking ‘is this the right time?’”
Rising interest rates combined with an increase in the cost of living would continue to make life tough for homeowners, Nagel said, “especially the highly leveraged and those who purchased at the peak of the market”.
The average rate of decline continued to slow in the lead-up to Christmas, he said.
But with talk of a recession, “we can expect further downward pressure on prices well into 2023 before we might eventually see the market bottom out later in the year”.
Lloyd said there were more properties for sale than in any other month on record in November. “Now is typically when we see the market really take off and despite prices falling, this year is no exception.”
On the other hand, Lloyd said demand had slowed down nationwide.
“These supply and demand changes really show us how the market has been flipped on its head. After years of seeing supply failing to keep up with sky-high demand, we’re now seeing the total opposite. Demand has fallen off while supply is skyrocketing, and prices are tumbling as a result,” he said.
“It appears buyers are waiting to see how far prices will fall, before they make a move.”
