In fact, the NZX-50 has now risen almost 300 per cent since its last low point - a decade ago in February 2009.
"Breaking through the magic 10,000 mark is a great milestone for the New Zealand market, said NZX chief executive Mark Peterson.
"It is definitely a milestone worth celebrating, and reaffirms how well our market continues to perform compared to our global peers. By comparison the S&P/ASX 200 index is up 170 per cent over this same period."
The NZX-50 returns are calculated on a gross index basis - with dividends factored in.
If you just looked at the capital return that would be more like 30 per cent up on the last peak in 2007, Lister noted.
However it had still been a "stellar run" for investors and KiwiSavers, he said.
The index had doubled from the 5000 point mark in almost exactly five years - representing annual returns of close to 14 per cent.
The strong bull run appeared to be at an end late last year. Global markets tumbled by almost 20 per cent between October and December - just shy of what investment analysts would have called a bear market.
However a reversal of central bank policy on interest rates - initially in the US - has seen money pour back into equity markets this year as investors seek better returns.
Some big equity fund managers have expressed nervousness about the heady heights the market is now reaching and the valuations of some companies.
It was important not to take annual returns in the double digits for granted, Lister said.
It needed to be acknowledged that this was a golden period.
"Thirteen or 14 per cent returns is not normal, it's exceptional. Over the long run the average is more like seven per cent. So don't get too comfortable and assume the next five or 10 years will go the same way because I strongly suspect they won't."
However, the strength of the sharemarket was also an indication of an economy which was still performing well despite the lack of confidence in some quarters, he said.
"We've got a lot of great businesses on our market now and it's a much more diverse market than it was five to 10 years ago, with more interesting companies doing interesting things offshore. I think it's something we should celebrate."
Locally, a combination of low inflation data - which now points to Reserve Bank interest rate cuts - and the Government's backdown on the Capital Gains Tax (which would have hit company valuations) seemed to have given the NZX another boost in the past week, Lister said.