The fewest unemployed people for each U.S. job opening since April 2001 would typically point to stronger wage growth as employers vie to lure and retain workers. Yet, year-over-year worker pay gains have struggled to break away from a 2 percent average that's persisted since the start of this expansion, befuddling economists.
In Silicon Valley, where technology companies feel the strains of an especially tight job market, employers are enticing workers with buzz phrases like "unlimited vacation" and "paid-paid vacation." As the jobless rate drops further through the Federal Reserve's defined range of full employment, hiring managers across industries should feel the pressure to pony up.
Grant Thornton, the sixth-largest U.S. accounting firm, said Wednesday it will offer U.S. employees unlimited time off.
With unlimited vacation, companies don't institute a set number of days per year for an employee to get away. Instead, time off is flexible, dependent on adjustments made by other workers to ensure the business doesn't skip a beat. So-called paid-paid vacation takes the policy one step further, offering a bonus earmarked solely for days off.
"It makes economic sense," said Drew Lawrence, FullContact's director of business development. As long as employees don't leave co-workers in a lurch, everyone returns from their time off as ready as ever to meet their targets, with minimal interruptions to clients, he said.
Matt Rizai, chief executive officer of data analytics company Workiva, sees additional rewards: "if they're happy, they're more productive, and if they're more productive, we do better business."
There's a lot more science coming out about the actual impacts of not taking time off. Managers are starting to look at these things more holistically.
Workiva, founded in 2008, started by offering a standard two-week vacation, and now allows up to twice as much. Last year, 85 percent of the company's 953 full-time employees used their allotted paid time off, according to Kevin McCarthy, Workiva's senior public relations manager.
That beats the national average. Just 25 percent of employees had used all of their paid time off in the prior 12 months, according to an April 2014 survey by online job-search network Glassdoor Inc. When employees did take vacation, 33 percent reported working because "no one else at my company can do" the job and 28 percent said they feared "getting behind."
More time off may turn out to be cheaper in the end, said Harry Holzer, public policy professor at Georgetown University.
"When you give somebody a wage increase, the expectation is that's there forever, and the next year you have to build on that, whereas with paid vacation, it's not as obvious that it goes into the base," said the former Labor Department chief economist.
More leave also shows that companies are weighing these costs against what they might otherwise spend to keep their employees healthy, said Jennifer Schramm, manager of workforce trends and forecasting at the Society for Human Resource Management, which has more than 275,000 members in about 160 countries, according to its website.
"There's a lot more science coming out about the actual impacts of not taking time off," said Schramm. Managers "are starting to look at these things more holistically."
The current generation has a slower transition to independence -- they spend more time living in their parents' houses, they marry later, they have kids later.
So far, there's little evidence that more creative vacation benefits are spreading beyond the technology industry.
While almost all U.S. companies offer some form of paid time off or vacation, only about 2 percent provide unlimited paid time off and fewer than 1 percent have unlimited paid vacation plans, according to an annual benefits survey released in June by SHRM. Almost none said they planned to institute these types of "unlimited" policies in the next year.
Small-business owner Tom Corcoran found inspiration for a different kind of vacation perk close to home. He borrowed the idea of a 10th anniversary sabbatical not from a digital wizard, but from Oak Brook, Illinois-based McDonald's Corp., where a family member benefited from the policy in the 1980s.
"It's a real nice, good thing that gets people to stay," especially considering workers switch jobs more frequently these days, said Corcoran. Each of 35 employees at his Corcoran Expositions Inc. in Chicago is allowed to take three months of paid time off after working a decade for the business. Two of his employees will take such leave next year.
More businesses also are lumping together all types of paid time off -- sick, personal and vacation days -- in an effort to provide more flexibility, Schramm said.
Broader benefits also may be a bid to attract millennials. Aged 18 to 34 this year, they represent the biggest share of the workforce and place a higher premium on flexibility than paychecks. Almost three-quarters said they'd be willing to trade 15 percent of their salaries in exchange for a better balance between work and other activities, according to a May 2012 report by Rutgers University's Center for Workforce Development.
"The current generation has a slower transition to independence -- they spend more time living in their parents' houses, they marry later, they have kids later," Holzer said. "All of which enables them to be a little more easygoing about exactly what wage they get."
