Milford's Active Growth fund was the strongest overall performer of the year, with a 26.4 per cent return.
Milford's greater allocation to shares also helped its conservative and balanced funds dominate their categories.
Aon KiwiSaver Russell, AMP, ANZ, and SIL also deserved mention for consistently strong results across a number of risk profiles, Morningstar said.
Over a five-year period, moderate funds - those with more money in cash and bonds - have the highest average return at 6.1 per cent a year. Conservative funds have performed second best over that period, with an average return of 5.9 per cent a year.
Douglas said the first quarter of 2013 was a busy time for KiwiSaver providers, with a number electing to close their schemes to new investors.
"Importantly, you don't need to rush any decision, as your money will continue to be managed in the same manner for some months to come while a scheme is either merged into another one or a final decision is made about its future," he said.
AMP Wealth (formerly AXA), National Bank, and ASB's FirstChoice KiwiSaver have all closed to new investors.
Douglas said individuals' savings pools were growing, meaning it was important that people made the right decision about which risk profile to choose.
"Now could be a very good time to reassess whether the risk profile you're invested in is the most appropriate given your age, time to retirement, and risk capacity."
There is now $14.48 billion invested in KiwiSaver, an increase of $825 million since three monthsago.
ANZ-owned One Path is the largest provider with $3.64 billion, ahead of ASB with $3.05 billion.
The top default provider both in 2012 and since 2008 was ANZ, its OnePath Conservative fund offering investors a return of 8.5 per cent a year and 6.3 per cent a year respectively.