Whakarewarewa came close to exacting some revenge against Te Puke in front of their home supporters in Rotorua, but fell just short losing 23-15.
Heavyweights Te Puke defeated Whaka on Saturday during their round three fixture in the Baywide premier competition at Puarenga Park - repeating the same result from last season's semifinal.
Whaka only trailed by one point with about 15 minutes to go in the match before Te Puke's Grayden Sheres crossed for a try to help his team get home.
"We were a bit disappointed, I guess for us there was a few missed opportunities," Whaka coach Kopae Irihei said.
"Te Puke have been a strong side for the last couple of years and are one of the benchmark teams in this competition. We certainly had opportunities and when you play against teams like that, you have to take them."