Rotoiti have taken the Tai Mitchell Shield off Whakarewarewa during a tryless encounter at Puarenga Park.
A penalty from Curtis Van Der Heyden and three more from former Steamers captain Willie Ripia helped Rotoiti win 12-3 on Saturday.
While the match was the equivalent of a pre-season game, it was apparent from the outset neither side was treating it that way. Both forward packs battled hard in the awful conditions and, in the end, the two sides were only separated by a couple of penalties.
The encounter was part of the Central Bay of Plenty local round which is being held this year ahead of the Baywide premier and first division competitions starting on May 2.
New Rotoiti coach Dave McLean said it was a great result for the club to beat rivals Whaka and win back the prestigious Tai Mitchell Shield, which is a historic trophy contested between Rotorua rugby clubs.