Councillor Rob Kent accused mayor Steve Chadwick of breaking the law while members of the public yelled "shame on you" to councillors, during a dramatic final council meeting of 2015.
Yesterday's Rotorua Lakes Council meeting was attended by several members of Te Arawa and the Rotorua District Residents and Ratepayers society.
At the beginning of the meeting Mr Kent said Mrs Chadwick had made serious breaches of the law in her "shameful dismissal of councillor Searancke".
Mrs Searanke, who has been a councillor for almost 30 years, was stripped of her roles as leader of the council's Creative Communities portfolio and the council's representative on the Bay of Plenty Regional Council's public transport sub-committee.
Mr Kent was one of six councillors who voted against the meeting moving into confidentiality to discuss the issue of Mrs Searancke's stripped roles. The motion was carried seven to six.