Love him or hate him, Shane Jones' departure from Labour is going to hurt the party.
With senior leaders who struggle to fire in the house, Jones certainly had the gift of the gab.
He could shoot down opponents like few others, and his quick wit and knowledge of things Maori were big bonuses for the struggling left.
While some say his lack of enthusiasm for politics meant it was time to go, the timing is pretty awful.
But his shock resignation doesn't have to be bad news for Labour in the long run.