But they will now, we hope, be putting their heads together to make sure they present the best case to Jetstar over the coming months.
Rotorua is up against cities, including Hamilton, New Plymouth, Napier, Palmerston North, Nelson and Invercargill.
All will have pros and cons for the airline and presumably all are keen to become a chosen city.
The obvious thing working in Rotorua's favour must be its appeal as a tourist destination. But ordinary residents would also benefit, whether they use the airport once a year to visit Grandma down south or once a week for business meetings in Auckland.
In a year that's seen the end of direct Sydney flights, it would be a boost for Rotorua's airport and the city as a whole to see the bright orange planes parked alongside the familiar blue and white ones come December.
Fingers crossed.