"Tauranga City Council has instigated and supported walking programmes," he said.
"Why allow cyclists access to our footpath when they have a flat tar-sealed street with very few cars? Why can't they stay on the road?"
Mr Simpson and three supporters also put their case before council, calling on it to widen the footpath to 3m and create a shared facility, which would cost about $45,000. The council would pay $21,150 of that and the New Zealand Transport Agency would fund the rest.
But councillors opted to create a bylaw which would allow for both sides to use the footpath.
They would look at widening it as part of the council's Minor Works Programme for 2014/2015.
Deputy Mayor Kelvin Clout said the council was hesitant to spend $21,000 on the project given current debts. "I am very aware we are talking about spending a lot of ratepayers' funds on a footpath which for now can be shared," he said.