A bronze whaler swimming close to shore sent swimmers scurrying from the surf at Papamoa Beach but a marine expert says the shark species does not usually present a threat to bathers.
On Tuesday, beachgoers had close encounters with the bronze whaler, with one person noticing it was just half a metre from where he was swimming.
Two hours later, a shark was seen splashing around in the shallows. It was unclear whether it was the same shark.
Department of Conservation marine scientist Clinton Duffy said bronze whalers were a common sight at Bay beaches in summer and people should not panic on sighting the species.
The only person to be killed by a bronze whaler in New Zealand was a spear fisherman at Te Kaha in 1976, Mr Duffy said.