The debate, such as it is, is reminiscent of the arguments when the law requiring seat belts was introduced. The same tired old objections were trotted out then - we should be allowed to make our own decisions and "a seat belt won't help, but will make it more difficult to escape from a burning car".
But, with the carnage on our roads refusing to reduce and the undeniable evidence that the injuries suffered by those not wearing seat belts are greater than they need be, that debate seems now pretty much resolved.
But was there ever any substance in the argument that the decision on whether or not to wear seatbelts (or lifejackets) should be left to individual choice? Is it really the case it is no one else's business and there is no wider interest in trying to bring down the drowning toll?
The first point to make is that the owner or skipper of the boat is usually not the only one involved. There will almost always be others on board and they will usually do what the skipper tells them or at least follow his example. If they are children, or inexperienced at sea, the skipper has a special responsibility to them and their families to set the right example.
And that is to say nothing of those, professionals or volunteers, who might be required to risk their own lives to save those whose lives are threatened because they couldn't be bothered to look after themselves.
But the consequences of setting the wrong example, with the result that lives are unnecessarily lost, go wider than that. Every life lost at sea will impact on others and will have consequences that society as a whole will often have to deal with. As the poet John Donne famously said, "No man is an island unto himself". A family member who drowns will leave behind not just a sense of loss and grief for the bereaved family but perhaps, as well, dependants who will need to be supported - and such burdens will often become the responsibility of society.
We all have an interest, in other words, in trying to save lives through such small, practical (and surely not difficult) measures as wearing seatbelts or installing smoke alarms or getting a Warrant of Fitness for our cars or wearing lifejackets. There is nothing very macho about not using your common sense and putting the lives of others unnecessarily at risk.
From our vantage point above the great Pacific Ocean as it rolls in inexorably and on to our beach, we have on memorable and tragic occasions watched as boats have got into trouble and have foundered on the rocks further along the coast, with - inevitably - loss of life. We have no wish to bear witness to similar tragedies in future, especially if they turn out to have been avoidable if only the simplest of precautions had been taken.
