My first proper visit there was to attend the Bethlehem Primary School's annual cow pat gala, something which has run for the past 21 years.
The event is based around the bowel movements of a cow with $2000 up for grabs depending on where it goes to the toilet on the school's field.
A strange introduction to a community, that's for sure, but it appeared to pay homage to Bethlehem's roots.
Many of the attendees told me of times when the suburb wasn't even a suburb but a small town with farmland surrounding it.
While that's not the case anymore, Bethlehem still kind of feels like a small town with some big-town aspects.
You can tell you're in a new suburb by the way the properties there look and how they differ from other areas surrounding them.
Walking still seems to be one of the main modes of transport, as well as cycling.
The state highway and the horrendous evening traffic out of the CBD certainly does its best to make Bethlehem as metropolitan as possible.
No doubt people who use the SH2 thoroughfare would be keen to see some changes and the Takitimu North Link sounds like a good idea.
Bethlehem's town centre appears to be its heartbeat, providing its visitors just about everything from food to fashion, medical supplies to entertainment.
It also gives the suburb a bit of a spruce up if you ask me, with retailers packed along the edges of the main drag.
There is a stark difference between the town centre here and the activity in Tauranga's CBD where many shops are vacant.
Apart from the traffic and the cowpat event, Bethlehem doesn't appear to make the headlines much, cruising along at its own peaceful pace.
It might seem to be the suburb where nothing much happens but driving through its quiet, leafy streets you soon realise that's not a bad thing - in fact, it's probably Bethlehem's best feature.