But voting statistics for the two major candidates - Ms Hipango and Ms Lewis - tell quite a different story.
While the statistics for South Taranaki were the same as the party vote - four polling booths to Ms Lewis, to Ms Hipango's 30 - in Whanganui Ms Lewis won nearly twice as many polling booths as Ms Hipango.
Voters at polling booths such as St Anne's School in Whanganui, Putiki Parish Hall, electorate headquarters in Taupō Quay, and the YMCA in Springvale gave their party votes to National but their candidate votes to Labour.
There was one polling booth for Whanganui at Massey University in Palmerston North. Voters at this booth had an even split between Labour and National in both party and candidate votes.
The Whanganui electorate vote included 10 prisoners who cast votes. Six voted for Labour, two for National and two for the Aotearoa Legalise Cannabis Party.
Of an estimated 56,770 eligible voters in Whanganui, 46,961 enrolled to vote. The total votes cast in the Whanganui electorate was 33,810 - a voter turn-out of 71 per cent. This was lower than the national average of 78.8 per cent.
These figures do not include special votes. The final election results will be released on October 7.