There was a new generation of players on both sides, but the 100-year rivalry which was relit last winter played out another competitive chapter on Saturday, as Whanganui Collegiate 1st XV finished just short of New Plymouth Boys High, 25-22.
The one-sided nature of these traditional fixtures had ceased last year when a very strong Collegiate team went to the intimidating Gully Ground in New Plymouth to upset NPBHS 32-26.
In the return game on Collegiate's No1 field, the new-look home side started strongly with No 8 Josefa Namosimalua leading the hitups, as Collegiate got over the tryline but were called back for a knock-on.
NPBHS then moved onto attack with winger Samuela Vakadula making a good run before Collegiate skipper and first-five Harry Godfrey cut him down, but the buildup led to a penalty for the visitors, which their first-five Jack Parker landed after it bounced over from the cross bar.
Collegiate's forwards worked hard to regain momentum, and earned a 17th penalty opportunity for halfback Adam Lennox to tie the scores.