Maggies Pies in Castlecliff had contents stolen from its outdoor chiller after it was broken into sometime Wednesday evening.
Josephine Erni owns the pie shop with her partner Bruce Leslie and said when they arrived to work at 3.30am on Thursday the padlock and security bar across the chiller door was gone and the contents of their chiller taken.
She believed the padlocks and bar were broken and taken off-site.
"I thought I was going loopy because I couldn't find them. You second guess yourself," she said.
She said pies, pastry, chicken, cheese, bacon, and mushrooms were taken.