As if we need anything else to worry about. Rising seas, raging pandemics, fake news, Trump's tweets… now I learn that the heat pump that warms my grandkids on winter mornings is a climate-destroyer extraordinaire. It's all to do with the gas inside it.
In 1987, pre heat pumps, governments banned ozone-destroying CFCs (chlorofluorocarbons) under the Montreal Protocol. Slowly the ozone hole began to shrink. Thirty years later one study estimated that 2 million fewer skin cancers per year will be diagnosed by 2030 thanks to this encouraging display of governmental cooperation.
Great. But. Turns out there's more to the story. Montreal was good for ozone but bad for the climate. Why? CFCs were replaced with HFCs (hydrofluorocarbons).
R410a, the most common HFC in heat pumps and air conditioners, has a GWP (Global Warming Potential) 1980 times that of CO2. Most car air-conditioners use HFC R134a which has a GWP 1430 times that of CO2. And then there's the refrigeration units in every corner store, supermarket, pub, dairy farmers' milk vat and bigger places like meat works, Fonterra milk factories… you get the idea. And they leak. Just like CFCs they eventually end up in the atmosphere.
My friend, whose home-built electric car has clocked up 55,000km, preventing 14 tonnes of CO2 from heating the atmosphere, figures his CO2 savings are cancelled out by the slow escape of gas from his neighbours' four ordinary-sized home heat pumps.