The question of Collegiate must be a vexed one for any Labour candidate or supporter in Wanganui, especially after Chris Hipkins' spray in Parliament.
Or for anyone who believes the state's role is to bolster public sector education, not private institutions.
Mr Hipkins, the opposition education spokesman, said on Thursday that the $3 million spend annually on the school post-integration was little benefit to taxpayers. Mr Hipkins said with just seven additional places for day students the taxpayer investment of $440,000 doesn't exactly represent value for money.
He advocates spending that money on other secondary schools in Wanganui to even-up the playing field.
There are problems with secondary schools in Wanganui - on the face of it one has too many and several have too few.