A woman who was convicted of obtaining a credit card by deception, and six counts of theft by a person in a special relationship, was jailed last week after Judge Deidre Orchard rejected her claims that her offending had been motivated by tikanga Māori and a desire to care for others.
Sentencing Toddy Shepherd in the Kaitaia District Court, Judge Orchard said she had been motivated by "nothing more complicated than greed," using the money she had taken from her employer, CCS Disability Action, to fund a lifestyle that she could not afford on her "perfectly reasonable" salary.
Shepherd was jailed for three years, with a discount of six months ("which is very generous and probably not justified") for her "good work" in the past and her good work since the offending as deputy CEO of Kaitaia's He Korowai Trust.
She was also ordered to pay reparation of $111,577.67, with an immediate payment of $3400, which she had offered prior to sentencing, the remainder in instalments.
The Crown had suggested a starting point of three and a half years' imprisonment, citing aggravating factors including that the money had been taken from a non-profit organisation over a more than three years and the defendant's lack of remorse. Defence counsel Rob Samuels argued for community detention, community work, intensive supervision and reparation.