The large medallion has an image of Pope John Paul II holding a crucifix on one side and Jesus and the Apostles on the other.
Then Kaitaia parish priest Fr John Dooley had given it to the Katavichs while having dinner at their home.
"He said Pope John Paul's bishop representative in New Zealand had told him to give it to someone worthy, and he thought we should have it," Mr Katavich said.
Asked how he felt about the medallion being followed by the Bene Merenti medals, he said: "We certainly never expected anything like this."
And Mrs Katavich said she was overwhelmed by the double papal awards.
"I was a bit tearful when we got the medals. I couldn't help myself crying," she said.