The i-Site will move out at the end of March, with no plans yet for a replacement, although Mr Carter has assured locals that the council will find a solution, and there is still plenty of space left on the Opononi site.
Peter Oldham, one of many residents who are concerned by the lack of consultation or warning about the decision to close the i-Site and lease the building to a private business, said that plan would also give the Opononi Four Square, with its bigger premises, plentiful parking and relatively low rent, a huge advantage over the store at Omapere.
Sue Jackson, owner of the Globetrekkers Lodge in Omapere, said squeezing the i-Site into a corner of the temporary Four Square had confused tourists and contributed to a drop in bookings. The decision to move the i-Site out long-term was made without talking to tourism operators or local residents.
"We pay our rates, then we get treated like this. It's a fait accompli," she said.
She was also concerned that the rebuilt shop could end up empty because Omapere and Opononi, with a combined winter population of fewer than 500, could not support three grocery stores.
Jackie Walker, also of Omapere, likened the "aesthetically incongruous" decision to turning Kaitaia's Te Ahu Centre into a Pak'nSave.
An initial plan to temporarily house the Four Square in the South Hokianga Memorial Hall was turned down by the hall committee, while the old old i-Site and museum building was demolished in 2010 when it was undermined by erosion.