A Far North man, who spoke to the Northland Age on condition of anonymity, says the draining of Lake Tangonge (the Kaitaia swamp) had a severe impact on the recharging of the Aupōuri aquifer, but the experts who believe the aquifer can continue to be exploited weren't listening.
Either they didn't understand the role the swamp once played, he said, or didn't accept it.
The aquifer has come into the spotlight once again courtesy of 24 applications to take more than six million cubic metres of water a year from it, after consents were granted for the taking of more than two million cubic metres last year.
The man, who has some experience in hydrology, said the experts who had modelled the aquifer's recharge had not taken account of the fact that 70,000 acres of hill country south of Kaitaia had once drained into the swamp. Draining the lake, which began in the early 1900s, had stopped or at least reduced recharging of the aquifer.
"Photos and news reports from the 1930s indicate that the lake flooded as high as Grigg's Corner, in Kaitaia, covering 10,000 acres or more of the Kaitaia flats," he said.