Korora Park offered the only realistic alternative for parking, with Mr Cammell suggesting a trial to see how it worked.
Meanwhile, Te Hiku Community Board would be following a consultation process, even if everyone who gathered to hear him last week agreed that the idea was a good one.
"The council doesn't want to do anything behind anyone's back," he added. "That's not the way the council does things."
The general reaction was not entirely positive, however. One man noted that there was a privately-owned camp ground a few hundred metres from the beach access that could be used by the owners of $300,000 motor homes, "The meanest people God put breath into."
Others noted a lack of signage directing motorists to Foreshore Road, where parking was available; some said the loss of part of the reserve would limit its use as a playground; one said the land had been gifted to the council by its Maori owners as a reserve, not a parking area; others arguing that a parking area would need toilets and rubbish bins.