Wellsford broke a nine-year losing streak at Hikurangi to remain unbeaten and top of the Southern Districts club rugby competition.
With five minutes to play Hikurangi looked to have sealed Saturday's game with a late try, but a penalty in the last play of the game gave Wellsford the win, 26-24.
Hikurangi coach Hector Davies said the game was an 80-minute arm wrestle but unfortunately the result didn't go their way.
Hikurangi scored first points through a successful penalty kick from Noel Edmonds, before Wellsford replied with a try scored and converted by Matthew Wright. Wellsford were rewarded for a sustained period of attack deep in Hikurangi's half with a try to Ian Neal out wide - giving them the lead 18-17 at the break.
The score remained unchanged for most of the half until Wellsford scored an unconverted try through winger Dylan Lewis, after a chip-kick from first-five Johnny Moimoi was regathered and spread wide. Late in the second half Hikurangi staged a comeback with a bit of luck and a chip-kick of their own. Fullback Troy Raitt regathered the kick and scored under the posts to make the score 24-23 to Hikurangi with only minutes remaining.