Hikurangi coach Vicki Gribble, who has taken over the head coaching reigns from Meredith McInnes, said the encounter versus Old Girls was a close affair the whole way through.
"Old Girls created a lot more chances. I think we defended quite well, we absorbed a lot of pressure," she said.
"Our goalkeeper was outstanding and that kept us in the game. Even though we scored first, we just cocked it up in the last five [minutes]."
With a mixed bag of results for Hikurangi so far this year, coming close to toppling competition heavyweights Old Girls was a pleasing exercise for the strong defensive outfit.
"We're improving, [it's] a bit late in the season but [we're] getting better," Gribble said.
In other premier matches, Hardie and Thompson Springfield dominated Echonorth Mangapai in an 11-nil drilling, while Real Deal Maungakaramea took control of their match versus Whangarei Girls' High School via a 6-4 win.
In the premier men's matches, Dempster and Hill Maungakaramea beat Bream Bay United 4-1 while Currie Electrical Springfield beat Morris and Morris Mangapai 3-1.
Results:
Premier Men, Round 10:
Springfield 3 Mangapai 1
Maungakaramea 4 Bream Bay United 1
Premier Women, Round 13:
Old Girls 2 Hikurangi 1
Springfield 11 Mangapai 0
Maungakaramea 6 Whangarei Girls' High 4.