"However, it is just the sort of rock that could be found in Maungataniwha Range to the south."
GNS Science's Nick Mortimer consulted this geological map of the Kaitaia area and said the colour and size of the rock marked it as being out of place in Kaingaroa. Photo/Supplied
Mortimer said he couldn't say how the rock could have gotten to where it was found, but a local explanation was likely - it could have been carried by a person or stream.
"Or maybe it's a new occurrence for the area and, one day, geologists will have to change the map."
Mortimer said it was difficult to make a definite identification without seeing the rock in person, but he thought it was probably not scientifically significant.
"Sadly, in all my time as a geologist at GNS Science I have always had to answer 'no' to the meteorite question."
Mortimer said he thought the proximity to what Urlich believed was a crater was coincidental, although "meteorites do turn up from time to time".