The Fencibles' right back - despite Alabaster's halftime warnings - was allowed to travel through the defence and scored a good goal to rock the home side's morale just 10 minutes into the second half.
Northland continued to turn over ball cheaply and lacked discipline and patience both in attack and defence but finally managed a rare moment of real attacking class.
Junior Kairaki lifted a free kick into the area from deep on the right and Jason Teal rose above the defenders in a crowded box to head the ball into the top left-hand corner of the net.
The fantastic goal lifted the side but any chance of their first win was dealt a serious blow when experienced striker Steve Schimmel received a second yellow card soon afterward.
"Steve reckoned the guy tripped over his own feet and he hadn't even touched him, so he may have been a bit unlucky," Alabaster said.
While the visitors looked more likely to break the deadlock in the final quarter, Northland held on grimly to claim its first point of the campaign.
The reserves continue to sparkle in their competition with a 6-1 thrashing of the visiting reserve side in the curtain raiser.
Langi Elisala opened the scoring in the first minute followed by a Mitch Hanmore strike in the 10th minute.
Fencibles pulled one back before Steve Crowley knocked in two goals in two minutes to take a 4-1 halftime lead. Daniel Hanmore and Ben Mortimer finished the scoring off in the second half.
Northland FC face a tough task today with their first away trip of the season against Te Atatu and they may struggle for numbers with a number of injuries and suspensions to contend with.