Words: Kim Knight
Design: Laura Hutchins
With thanks to: Rick Fennell (Ross Goldfields Information & Heritage Centre), Sue Asplin (Hokitika Museum) and Julia Bradshaw (Canterbury Museum).
John Scott was pickaxing the silty blue pug out the back of Healey’s Hotel when he found it - a gold nugget, as big as his hand and as heavy as a brick.
He’d been working the claim with his mate Arthur Sharpe. Some said the site was jinxed - two decades earlier, another miner had fallen into his own tailrace and broken his neck. Scott and Sharpe were going over old ground but in 1909, on the edge of the West Coast town of Ross, they’d hit the very definition of pay dirt.
The Press newspaper reported that Scott and Sharpe played their good fortune cool. They laid the nugget to one side and covered it with a hat.
At knock off, they rolled the gold into the nape of a coat and strolled to the pub. Two miners, at the hard luck end of the first Ross gold rush, walking into history.
The nugget was - and still is - the heaviest ever discovered in New Zealand.
Officially unearthed on Friday, September 10, 1909 in Ross, a small goldmining town about 27km south of Hokitika, it weighed in at an old school 99ozs 12dwts 12grs - around three kilograms by today’s reckoning. (Gold prices change by the minute and value depends on purity but, based on a recent check with the New Zealand Mint, three kilograms of pure gold would currently fetch around $312,000).
Some reports suggested Scott and Sharpe had actually been sitting on the find for more than a week. Later still, there would be a claim the nugget was an Australian import. But there was a bigger mystery to come.
They called it the “Rose of Ross” and the “Welcome Stranger”. Later, when it seemed all of the district’s gold was gone, it was dubbed “The Last of the Mohicans”. The massive nugget toured the country, was raffled to raise funds for a hospital and taken to England as a coronation gift for King George V.
And then the Royal Family lost it.
Sometime between 1911 and now, 3kg of West Coast gold disappeared from Buckingham Palace. Multiple attempts to locate the missing gold have failed. What happened to this record-breaking piece of New Zealand’s geological history? And why did we give it away in the first place?
“To London, Sir Joseph will lug it,
That really desirable nugget;
And ask King George to graciously accept it.
Then the folks will all form the opinion,
That we, in this lucky Dominion,
Don’t want such things, or surely we’d have kept it.”
- By Old Salt, Auckland Star, March 8, 1911
“I am, in fact, the granddaughter of John Scott,”
begins Mrs Beverley Roberts. A typed document, retrieved from the Hokitika Museum archives, recounts the Scott family’s story of the momentous discovery. Apparently, the land that was being prospected contained a track with a lumpy section that caused frequent stumbles and “aroused a frequently heard intention of going up the track with a pickaxe to remove the offending rock”.
One day, writes Beverley, “the intention was carried out and the nugget duly and joyfully discovered”.
Beverley’s father was Herbert Stanley Scott, born in 1896, and raised in Kūmara. He remembers being taken to an uncle’s house one evening to see the nugget - wrapped in a blanket, stuffed inside a large biscuit tin and stashed under the bed.
“Little Bertie was given the honour of holding the nugget, but being young and not very tall for his age, he managed to drop the precious object and be soundly told off by all the adults!”
Gold town, Boom town
Ross was born in the rush of 1865.
In the week that gold was discovered the area’s population was 250 people. Within three weeks it had swollen to 2000 and, writes Philip Ross May in his book Goldtown, a month after that it was 4000.
In those early, fevered days, the West Coast was home to just 12 per cent of New Zealand’s European population, but a full quarter of all the men aged between 21 and 40. Reverend James Buller (who made 26 river crossings to bring godliness from Canterbury to Hokitika and had to sleep under a shop counter when no spare beds could be found) remarked upon arrival: “Nothing populates a waste howling wilderness like gold.”
Certain civilisations have spent millenia mythologising this precious metal. Love is declared with gold rings, triumphs rewarded with gold medals - and wealth stored in gold bars. In 18th century Westland, where the bush was thick and the rain fell hard, where farming and agricultural success was not as easy as it was “over the hill” on the Canterbury plains, gold was the mineral that brought new in their droves. According to one historic estimate, between 1865 and the turn of the century, the Ross Flat produced more than 10 tonnes of gold.
There’s still gold in the town’s alluvial gravels. Birchfields Ross Mining runs an open cast operation here. One huge pit, just behind the tiny settlement, is now a lake. Speaking to the Greymouth Star in 2009, owner Evan Birchfield said, “Rogernomics forced us to go gold mining and I’ve never regretted it”.
According to Birchfield, there was “no doubt” nuggets as big (or even bigger) than the 1909 find had gone over his screens and not been caught. The modern-day mine was mostly about collecting fine gold, but, he said, there were constant encounters with the past.
“Some of my trucks have toppled over when the ground has given way to shafts,” Birchfield reported. “We have been down 45 metres below sea level and still come across shafts where the old timers have been - amazing.”
Philip May Ross (the author and historian whose father was a former mayor of this historic town) writes comprehensively and evocatively of the years that followed the initial Ross rush. By the first decade of the new century, he says, the brash young digger of the 1860s who made the Ross district his home would have experienced almost the entire gold mining world in miniature:
“The deep ground at Ross was a piece of Victoria, the high gravels of the Mont d’Or a little California, the dredging claims were Otago and the bush and the rain - those ubiquitous elements which governed local mining - were peculiarly Westland.”
That small rectangle of land, measuring roughly five by 10 kilometres and bound on one side by the Tasman Sea represented “virtually the full suite of gold deposits and the full range of mining methods to work them”.
In the late 1800s, gold mining technology changed drastically and quickly (from pans and shovels to steam-engine driven pumps), but in the new century, a very grand scheme was afoot. Government had a plan to “unwater” the deep levels of the Ross Flat. The plan would allow for the extraction of gold - and the water would be used to produce electricity. It took several years and cost tens of thousands of pounds but, on September 8, 1909, they pressed the buttons and the pumps started up. Ross Goldfields Ltd was in operation. And then, two days later, quite close to the edges of the new company’s claim, that record-breaking nugget was found.
Philip May Ross: “Big nuggets had been as rare as pukekos’ teeth on the Ross Flat but now, at the propitious moment and in ground worked for half a century, a fist sized nugget sprang forth to gladden the hearts of the Company directors and encourage the shareholders, to provide Rossites with a cause for a champagne christening and their chronicler with a subject for idle speculation.”
A golden fortune goes on tour
They dubbed it the “Hon Roddy Nugget”. The golden fortune was named for the then Minister of Mines, Roderick Mackenzie, baptised with champagne and feted from pub to pub.
But was it a plant? An interloper designed to bolster faith in that expensive and extensive new gold mining and electricity scheme?
“Sir - There are not a few persons who now firmly believe that the ‘Hon Roddy’ nugget was brought over from Victoria to be so coincidentally found only a foot or two from the boundary of the Ross Goldfields area. I am, etc, WATCHFUL.”
- Letter to the Editor, Grey River Argus, February 26, 1910.
Cue outrage from R. Pedrazzi Snr who wrote back to the newspaper “emphatically” vouching for Ross nugget: “If ‘Watchful' (behind the fence of anonymity) or any other person can prove my statement incorrect, I will forward a cheque of £100 to the Greymouth Hospital.”
Did Mr Pedrazzi have skin in this gold game? Sir James McNeish wrote about the Roddy Nugget in his book Tavern in the Town (“still the last word on New Zealand’s most colourful pubs” according to the jacket blurb of the 1966 reprint). He introduces the pivotal Ross characters in the “what happened next” tale of the Hon Roddy - namely Louis Pedrazzi, who made a celebrated, garlicky salami and owned a tiny wooden pub called the City and Cantabrian James Free. The two men (and possibly a third called “Ross” according to some newspaper reports) pooled their resources and bought the nugget for four hundred pounds.
McNeish: “For four days, he sat on the bar top counter uninsured, as a holder of matchsticks. For variation, Louis used him as a doorstop. Visitors flocked in. The sleepy township of Ross awoke with a bang.”
There had, wrote McNeish, been nothing like it since the inspecting engineer of mines returned from Melbourne with a new engine and a boatload of dancing girls.
“Roddy led a wonderful life. He was photographed, handled, kissed and toasted in every brand of spirits the bar could supply. Then he left to ‘further his education’.”
Pedrazzi and Free had turned down several purchase offers (including one from the Christchurch Cycling and Motor Company), but they would eventually sell The Roddy for good.
The nugget was bought for £450 as a fundraiser for the Ross Hospital and Messrs Archie Peebles, Bob Ford and Archie Gardiner took it on tour, selling raffle tickets around the country. Newspapers of the day proclaimed its arrival, from Christchurch to Wellington to Wanganui to Auckland. The Hon Roddy! The largest nugget yet discovered in the Dominion! One week only!
It was a splendid sample of gold, its lumps and bumps said to contain “the distinct shape of a man’s face” or, viewed from another angle, “it has the impression of a lady’s shoe”. And all that gold could be yours for just five shillings.
Some commentators later described the raffle of the Roddy as the original “Golden Kiwi” - the national lottery that grew out of the Art Union raffles and operated from 1961 until 1989, when New Zealanders began to favour the newer, shinier (and televised) Lotto. In 1910, only print journalists were there to record a very complicated prize draw, overseen by two West Coast mayors and three local dignitaries.
First, two cylinders were prepared. In one, the officials placed a blank pellet for every ticket sold. Then they repeated that process with a second cylinder, marking just one pellet with the magic word. For more than an hour, the men drew blanks. And then, on draw number 3131, the coveted word - “nugget” - was plucked from the second cylinder.
Reefton’s Percy Cohen claimed the gold. And, in the final paragraph of the Greymouth Evening Star’s report of the draw, there was an intriguing footnote: “The Roddy nugget has been purchased by Mr J. Murdoch (Mayor of Kūmara) for £400, on behalf of some residents of Christchurch.”
We now know the New Zealand Government bought the nugget to give to the king.
Fit for a king?
The Roddy gets a makeover
In June 1911, on the eve of his coronation, the Roddy nugget was presented to King George V by then prime minister Sir Joseph Ward - a gift from the king’s “loyal subjects”. But the nugget that was fit for a king bore little resemblance to the one that once held matchsticks on a hotel bar top on the West Coast.
A pedestal, designed and constructed by Wellington jewellers W. Littlejohn & Son, would ultimately be worth almost as much as the gold it was designed to carry. The elaborate mounting included four massive silver-clawed feet, a base of tōtara knot wood and a secondary mounting of gold leaf and pounamu. There was a small silver statue of a miner and several small quartz nuggets, polished to reveal their veins of gold. The Roddy sat atop all of this.
Documentation held by Archives New Zealand reveals the nugget and mounting were together insured for £750. Not everyone was enamoured with the purchase. The general election’s opposition candidate for Waipawa claimed the nugget was a bribe to the king in exchange for a baronetcy. Francis Fisher (standing in Wellington Central for the Reform party) condemned the purchase in a diatribe against wasteful Government spending at a time when people were not even receiving a living wage. The public put pen to paper:
Sir - I rather think that if those presenting the gift had gone through even one of the palaces - say, Windsor - and seen the endless cases of gifts reaching nearly from floor to ceiling, they would have hesitated before adding another object to be crushed away into some corner . . . Why pile more wealth where it is absolutely not required and can do no good? Surely it would be a far wiser, more beautiful, and more practical policy to put the value of the nugget into some very much needed channel, say a fund to form a Cripples' Home, or a Home for Aged and Needy Governesses . . . I am, etc, ADMIRER.
- Letter to the Editor, Otago Daily Times, May 17, 1911
As far as coronation gifts from the bottom of the world went, the Roddy nugget was singularly impressive. In 1902, for example, New Zealand gave King Edward VII a miniature whare whakairo (carved meeting house), inlaid with small discs of mother of pearl. In 1953, we clubbed together with the governments of the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, South Africa, Pakistan, Ceylon and Southern Rhodesia to give Queen Elizabeth II a pair of oval, red velvet-lined and Tudor rose-decorated 22-carat gold bracelets.
What would King George V do with our gold nugget? "He can't wear it on his watch chain with comfort, and there is hardly room for it on his crown," noted the Greymouth Evening Star (April 4, 1911). "It might make a good paper weight, but then the Palace minions might sneak it, and sell it for beer, or something else equally as pleasing and deleterious. We suppose its final resting place will be in the Tower, along with the Crown jewels, and Queen Mary's hat pins."
There is no question the West Coast gold made it to London. The New Zealand Times reports the Roddy travelled from Wellington to Melbourne by the SS Warrimoo, before being transferred to the Orient liner Osterley and sailed to Naples, whereupon it was carried “overland” (with, presumably, at least one more sea journey) to London.
Archives New Zealand still holds much of the paperwork associated with this journey, including insurance documents and a request for the approval for £800 from the Unauthorised Expenditure Account to pay for the gift, its mounting and travel.
There is a letter too from Downing Street, London, to the then Governor of New Zealand thanking the country for both the nugget and the accompanying addresses of loyalty - one from women of New Zealand to Queen Mary and one “on behalf of the Māori Race to their Majesties”.
King George V’s coronation was, at the time, the most expensive ever. It cost £2.5m and, according to cabled reports from the day, “no language can exaggerate the splendour and effect of the great spectacle which London witnessed”. There was pomp and there was ceremony. There were 24 carriages, traversing a lavishly decorated five-mile route, overseen by 25,000 police officers. Somewhere, in the middle of all this splendour, was a gold nugget retrieved from the blue puggy ground of Westland.
Is there still gold in that thar hill?
Modern day Ross is a blink-and-you’ll-miss it town, prettily heralded by an avenue of flowering cherries and most recently famous as an overnight stop on the West Coast Wilderness cycle trail. The Historic Empire Hotel does an outrageously good burger, $5 will get you the key to the covered town swimming pool - and $10-$20 will pay for the hire of a gold pan and expert tips from the Ross Goldfields Information & Heritage Centre.
“The thing is, you can still go up Jones’ Creek and if you’re lucky - or if you know what you’re doing, probably more like it - you still come away with half a dozen flakes,” says Rick Fennell, centre manager.
“Probably not even enough to buy you a jug, but it’s still there. You can still find it with just a pan and a shovel.”
Fennell has had an interest in Ross since the 1980s when he worked with the teams that developed the historic goldfields walks behind the Heritage Centre. It’s been a tough few pandemic years keeping it all afloat, he says. Tour bus traffic dried up for a long time and independent travellers aren’t so inclined to splash their cash.
“They rock up in their $300,000 motor caravans looking for freedom parking and they’ll put 50 cents in the donation box and say ‘there’s my bit to help the community’.”
The Heritage Centre, in the old Bank of New South Wales building, is classic small-town museum stuff. Photocopied newspaper articles, hand painted dioramas, lots of photographs and a video on loop. In a cabinet in the centre of the room, on a fold of red velvet brocade, a replica of The Hon Roddy Nugget.
“Quite a few people know about it,” says Fennell. “Quite a few people come in looking for it. There’s so many stories. That it wasn’t from here, that it was planted, but one of the locals on the committee, he reckoned his great grandfather vouched that it was found here.”
Every so often, says Fennell, a geologist will stop by and they’ll get talking. Could another Roddy be lurking in the Ross dirt?
“They reckon it could be possible. There could be a slip come down from up the hill and bring a lump with it. The mountain, Mount Greenland, its French name is Mont d’or - mountain of gold.
“There’s got to be gold still up there. One geologist from California, back in ‘93, he said Mount Greenland was like a pimple of gold. He said if you could squeeze it, it’d be bloody good.”
Famous Nugget Disappears
This is not the first - or even the second or third time - someone has wondered about the Roddy Nugget. Fennell thought he might have been onto something recently, when tourists put him in touch with their friend who worked at the Tower of London, where the Crown Jewels are kept. Sadly, the contact died before inquiries could progress.
Locally, the accepted fate of the gold is that it was melted down and turned into a tea set. Weekend Herald inquiries turned up multiple references to that tea set but we also found claims that the gold became, variously, a plate, knives and forks and, more simply, bullion. What we couldn’t find? Concrete evidence that any of these alleged permutations existed in anything other than media reports.
There are at least two replica Roddys on the West Coast. One, held in the Hokitika Museum collection, is currently in storage. The Ross replica is owned by Canterbury Museum. Fennell is not sure how old the cast is, but he renews the lease agreement every couple of years. (In 1909, the Herald reported a “brilliant addition” to the contents of the Canterbury Museum - facsimiles of famous and historical diamonds, including the Hope, the Green Dresden and the Tiffany. As an aside, the report noted, “the museum has also secured a cast of the Hon. Roddy nugget”).
“Famous Nugget Disappears” says the headline from 1957. An interview with James McNeish revealed that, as part of the research for his Taverns book, he’d made no headway with an inquiry to the Queen’s private secretary and the Geological Museum in London which had subsequently approached the British and Victoria and Albert Museums on his behalf.
Forty years later, Ross local, K. Detlaff Esq received a similarly disappointing letter from an assistant registrar with the Royal Collection Department in London: “The only reference I found was in the index to the private secretary’s files of George V’s reign . . . unfortunately, many of the files in that series were weeded out years ago, and I could not find this file, I must assume that it was destroyed.”
There was yet another unsuccessful inquiry in 2008, when preparations for the 100th anniversary of the Roddy’s discovery were underway. An archives assistant replied: “It has proved impossible to find further information”.
Might the increasingly digitised nature of history turn up anything new in 2023? Back in February, we wrote to King Charles III imploring him to take a personal interest in the disappearance of the nugget. He had, after all, once tried his very own hand at panning for West Coast gold on a visit to Shantytown, the replica historic mining town 60km north of Ross.
“We sincerely hope this letter may have piqued your interest in helping solve the mystery of the whereabouts of any aspect of this significant piece of New Zealand history . . . “
The king did not reply.
Historic documents record the Hon Roddy’s journey from Aotearoa to London. Images / Archives New Zealand Te Rua Mahara o te Kāwanatanga - Communicate New Zealand Collection
Last year, a Cornish history blog sought to quantify just how much gold the Royal Family owned. The short answer was “a tremendous amount” but the more detailed calculation (including reserves from the Royal Mint) came out at $1.2 billion-plus.
Search the Royal Collections Trust database for “gold” and it throws up more than 5500 items. Not all of the estimated 1 million objects, representing 500 years of the Monarchy, have been digitally catalogued, but enter “New Zealand” into the database and it returns 277 references. From hei tiki and mere pounamu to a hand-painted jigsaw created by Kiwi Girl Guides, from a gilt metal mounted leather horse whip bound in royal racing colours to a portrait by Gottfried Lindauer. There is a complete set of New Zealand coins, dozens of photographs and books but not a single gold nugget - or even the pedestal it sat on.
We sent an email to the Royal Collection Trust’s media team.
“Many thanks for your patience,” wrote Lily Spicer, assistant press officer. “Our curator has previously searched for details about the gold nugget to no avail unfortunately - apologies not to be more helpful on that front.”
Why can’t The Roddy be found? What might have happened to the heaviest gold nugget ever found in Aotearoa?
“Apologies for the delay in getting back to you,” wrote Spicer. “We have been busier than usual due to the upcoming coronation. I’m afraid our curators are only able to give interviews in connection to current exhibitions and projects.”
Prime Minister Chris Hipkins recently revealed this country’s coronation gift to King Charles III. Next Saturday, while London is ablaze with pomp and ceremony and gold-plated carriages, New Zealanders will be encouraged to plant a tree.
The Government has donated $1 million to Trees That Count. It will work with the Department of Conservation and community groups to plant over 100,000 native trees in a project called He Rā Rākau Tītapu - King Charles III Coronation Plantings.
This time, the loyal subjects are not taking any chances.