Napier Gull management staff are relieved that police captured two of three youths just hours after they robbed the store early on Sunday morning.
They entered the store about 3am, using a baseball bat to threaten staff before making off with cigarettes.
Staff members were not injured and a police spokesperson said the quick arrests were made due to police recognising the thieves who have been referred to Youth Aid, but they were still looking for the third.
A staff member at the Napier Gull said he was thankful that two people had been caught, as it was the third time their store had been targeted in less than two years.
"It still doesn't help with the event that has just passed, but it's better that they were caught than not caught, in my opinion," he said. "The staff are shaken by what's occurred but they will come out of it with time.