No one was quite sure whether it was a step forward or a step backward.
But there was no question it was the right step, fermenting, as it were, for 26 years, but brewing only in the past 18 months.
It's a unique brewery which opened yesterday in the Westshore Beach Inn, where the punters can watch how it's done and have an ale at the same time. It may even be their own home brew.
It's a concept Westshore proprietor Jeremy Baylis started dreaming of in the days he was running the Criterion Hotel at the end of the 1980s and into the 1990s and embarking on a reshaping of Napier hotel and bar industry.
It started taking shape after he teamed up 18 months ago with Elephant Hill winemaker Damian Birchman, who with viticultural consultant Dr Mark Krasnow and stevedoring company surveyor Davron Adsett, had formed Bad Bay Beer Co.