I find Hawke's Bay Regional Council's response to Don't Frack the Bay's concerns about the make up of the Future Energy workshop to be quite revealing (Energy workshop exclusion dismays 6/5/15).
The workshop is the first step in HBRC's $200,000 consultation with the citizens of Hawke's Bay to develop a strategy about future energy use. DFTB welcomed this initiative which, thankfully, comes at a time when the immediate future of the oil & gas industry is on hold following the withdrawal of TAG Oil from the East Coast.
We have a golden opportunity to have a robust discussion about how we all see the future and develop a workable strategy for all without having the immediate pressure of the oil & gas industry hanging over our heads.
However, we are told by HBRC that the only people capable of undertaking "initial scoping" are territorial local authorities and corporate business. You don't have to be a rocket scientist to realise that the initial scoping is a vital first step in the process because it frames any future discussion around this issue.
The make up of the invitees is so lopsided that the outcome is inevitable - a continuation of the status quo. What's the point of going through this process if this is the case? As we asked HBRC, where is Maori representation? Where is the representation from our youth, who have a vested interest in the future? Who is representing the discussion around a not unrelated topic, Climate Change? Who is representing those most affected by energy issues, those in lower socio-economic situations? Who is representing farming about the use of fossil fuel-based fertilisers?