Hastings District Council has called for a review after sections of the newly resurfaced Waimarama Rd are already crumbling and breaking away.
The roadworks took a number of weeks and were completed in September.
When Hawke's Bay Today contacted the contractor, Russell Roads, a spokesman said the company had no comment as the council dealt with the road.
Hastings District councillor Bayden Barber, who was previously a member of the Rural Community Board, voiced his concerns at the state of the road at his last meeting on September 5.
"You could see that the quality was inadequate when they were laying the road, as corrugation was already appearing on the corners. It is cutting up bad already and the job was only completed in September," Mr Barber said.