The 1970s began promisingly for the club when the senior team won four consecutive matches at the beginning of the season. The team had a core of experienced players which included Waikare Ratima, who was an outstanding player and servant of the club. An annual rugby derby between Aotea and Patea’s Manawapou Club for the Beb Kahu Memorial Cup was also vigorously contested during this time.
1973 saw the establishment of two identical trophies by the family of the late Lui Paewai, one of the club’s favourite sons. The Dannevirke Rugby Sub-union awards the Lui Paewai Trophy to the team scoring the most tries in a season. The first winner of the trophy in 1973 was Dannevirke High School 1st XV. The second Lui Paewai Trophy, presented to the Dannevirke Golf Club, is still played for today.
1978 was a big year for the club when in June, it celebrated its 75th anniversary. Many former players attended, including Walter “Wattie” Barclay, George Nepia and Nitama Paewai, who all achieved national honours - Wattie as a captain and selector of the Māori All Blacks; George played for both the All Blacks and Māori All Blacks as well as the NZ Kiwis; and Nitama (”Doc”) played for the Māori All Blacks, and was a reserve on four occasions for the All Blacks but never played a match.
Aotea began the 1980s with a flurry of victories and built on this to win the Hunter Sheild, the Lui Paewai Trophy, the Central Hawkes Bay Rugby Sub-Union Cup and the Stubbs & Miller Challenge Knockout in 1981. The club’s junior team also had a victorious season, winning a trio of trophies, including the UFS Shield (for the top junior team), adeptly coached by Jim McNicol.