Hastings's first library had its beginnings in 1875, when James Boyle, who owned 100 acres (40 hectares) of land, donated a section for a library in Market St. In 1885, a reading room was built on that land as part of an Athenaeum, where a subscription library operated for 108 members.
After the government withdrew its subsidy, financial difficulties at the Athenaeum in 1901 meant the Hastings Borough Council, after some pressure, made its entry into the library arena.
When the council struck a special rate to pay for the library, there was a public uproar, which caused the council to retreat and put it in the general rate.
The original 1885 Athenaeum in Market St had become run down by 1903, and descriptions of it were made as "the worst in the colony" and a "rude barn".
The Scottish steel tycoon Andrew Carnegie had established a fund for establishing library buildings - but the library had to be subscription-free.