Henry's outward handling of the tournament-ending injury to Dan Carter, for one instance, was superb. In reality, the Canterbury No 10 was crucial to the campaign. His performance against France in the pool match was so effortlessly influential, that it didn't become fully obvious how much he was missed until the final against the same team.
As for McCaw, who got the nod ahead of a field that included fellow All Black flanker and possibly the better performer in 2011, Jerome Kaino, it came down to leadership and pure guts. Playing with a damaged foot throughout, he fronted week on week. And while he was not at his absolute best, the All Blacks were all the better for his presence.
The Halberg Awards generally create a few arguments, but this year they have honoured the major achievement of 2011. And they have pointed to the biggest event of 2012, the London Olympics - legendary shotputter Valerie Adams winning Sportswoman of the Year for the sixth time, and junior field athlete phenomenon, Jacko Gill, honoured as the emerging talent.
Once again the awards have also shown that our sportspeople continue to box above their weight, the Breakers, featuring our very own Paul Henare, a prime example of being unlucky on the night.