Urgent need for ETS changes: report

Pine tree pollen in Te Pohue. 3 September 2021 Hawke's Bay Today Photo by Paul Taylor HBG 04Sep21 - HBG 09Sep21 - Mostly harmless pine pollen, pictured over Te Pohue this week, is nevertheless annoying as it coats surfaces with yellow. Photo / Paul Taylor HBG 15Sep21 - Mostly harmless pine pollen, pictured over Te Pohue this week, is nevertheless annoying as it coats surfaces with yellow. Photo / Paul Taylor WGP 02Dec21 - The Native Forest Coalition fears exotic pine forests can have a 'catastrophic' effect of waterways when felled. Photo / File HBG 02Dec21 - The Native Forest Coalition fears exotic pine forests can have a 'catastrophic' effect of waterways when felled. Photo / File RGP 09Dec21 - The Native Forest Coalition fears exotic pine forests can have a 'catastrophic' effect of waterways when felled. Photo / File NAG 09Dec21 - The Native Forest Coalition fears exotic pine forests can have a 'catastrophic' effect of waterways when felled. Photo / File HBG 30Jun22 - Trees will be planted mainly on land now used for farming. HBG 09Aug22 - Pine pollen over forestry in Hawke's Bay last year. Photo / Paul Taylor HBG 11Aug22 - Pine pollen over forestry in Hawke's Bay last year. Photo / Paul Taylor NZH 07Oct22 - For targets to be reached, 200,000ha would need to be planted annually. Photo / Paul Taylor RGP 12Oct22 - The new policy looks set to favour forestry over sheep and beef production. HBG 12Oct22 - The new policy looks set to favour forestry over sheep and beef production. BTG 12Oct22 - The new policy looks set to favour forestry over sheep and beef production. NAG 12Oct22 - The new policy looks set to favour forestry over sheep and beef production. NZH 12Oct22 - The new policy looks set to favour forestry over sheep and beef production.

Consultation on potential changes to New Zealand’s Emissions Trading Scheme (ETS) closed yesterday and Beef + Lamb New Zealand has released an independent report on whether changes are needed to the ETS and if so, what these should be.

The recently completed analysis by New Zealand legal firm Meredith Connell was commissioned before the Government released its proposals for consultation.

B+LNZ chief executive Sam McIvor said the report would primarily be used to inform B+LNZ’s consultation submission on behalf of farmers, along with farmer feedback.

“B+LNZ has long argued that action needs to be taken to address the scale and pace of whole farms being sold into forestry as a result of the increasing carbon price and the resulting effects on rural communities,” Mr McIvor said.

“Many farmers also see opportunities to grow their income from carbon revenue from on-farm planting as part of diversifying their farm systems, so there needs to be a balance found in the policy settings.

“The report supports the need for urgent changes to the ETS, with the introduction of some limits on forestry offsets.”

Mr McIvor said the report noted that there needed to be a combination of short- and long-term changes to the ETS.

“The focus of the report is on changes to the permanent category of the ETS, as Meredith Connell’s view is that this is an area of the ETS that could be more quickly reformed, and that without limits this could also be a category that continues to drive significant land-use change.

“One of the main changes to the permanent category of the ETS it proposes is excluding exotic plantings except in limited circumstances.

“It notes that in future, however, further changes to the ETS that target other categories are likely to be required.

“The report outlines a number of options for long-term changes to the ETS that include some of the options put forward by the Government in its consultation.”

Mr McIvor said the report was another example of growing consensus on the need for policy changes to address the issue of wholesale land-use change.

“The scale and pace of land use change we are currently seeing is far more than what is recommended by the Climate Change Commission and will have a negative impact on rural communities, food production and export income, which affects all New Zealanders.

“New Zealand is one of the only countries in the world that allows fossil fuel emitters to offset 100 percent of their emissions.”

The report authors note: “Forestry offsets are a key component of a scheme designed to enable our country to meet emissions-reduction targets set in legislation. But they are a tool that must be managed in a way that enables sustainable and equitable social, economic, and environmental outcomes, for generations to come.”

Mr McIvor said B+LNZ would provide the Ministry for the Environment (MfE) with the Meredith Connell report.

B+LNZ has been given an extension to the deadline for submissions on ETS options to enable detailed Board consideration of B+LNZ’s submission document before it’s provided to MfE.

The final submission document will be published on the B+LNZ website when it’s finalised.

The report is available online at tinyurl.com/y7rffm7v