During a brief exchange between the chorus and Evangelist the chorus takes the part of torch and weapon-bearing high priests’ servants, then becomes the worshipful voice of the people again.
When Jesus outlines how he has freely talked he is struck by a servant. He is baffled — as is the collective voice in the chorale — but taken away.
Part 2 involves the trial and the chorus as a braying mob.
“If this man were not an evil-doer, we wouldn’t have turned Him over to you,” sing the chorus.
Pilate, the Roman prefect of Judaea, finds no fault in Jesus and after a brief exchange with him hands the responsibility for his fate to the chorus. The chorus brays for Barabbas, a rebel held by the Roman governor. When the soldiers set a crown of thorns upon Jesus’s head the chorus turns into even more of a rabble.
“Hail to you, dear King of the Jews!” they sneer.
“And gave him blows on the cheek”, says the Evangelist.
The story goes downhill from here for Christ.
Hell breaks looseFrom 5th century AD, performances of the passions (St John’s and St Matthew’s) evolved from recitations or chants by a single priest to a sense of drama between various players, writes Paul Kilbey in the The Bach Passions: An Introduction.
“By Bach’s time, the passion setting had morphed into a dramatic form with much in common with the oratorio,” says Wilson.
“It’s a real theatrical piece. You have that yowling crowd baying for blood. All hell breaks loose. The graunching chorus and cries of pain like the beast of the jungle crouching to spring. The tension is fantastic, it’s relentless.
“Regardless of what you believe, you believe like hell when you’re there. There’s never a dull moment but there are tranquil moments. I have one moment that is very reflective. It’s a moment of wonderful, wonderful calm. It’s a tremendous combination of these things.”